Jump to content

Welcome to Geeks to Go - Register now for FREE

Geeks To Go is a helpful hub, where thousands of volunteer geeks quickly serve friendly answers and support. Check out the forums and get free advice from the experts. Register now to gain access to all of our features, it's FREE and only takes one minute. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more.

Create Account How it Works

Do these security applications mean my XP sp2 machine is now invulnera

  • Please log in to reply




  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 36 posts
I am an average computer user.

Berkely Lab Computer Protection Program's Checklist( http://www.lbl.gov/c...-checklist.html ) for Securing Windows XP Systems has the following to say:

"Use only Windows XP Professional. Windows XP Home has too many major security flaws (e.g., in XP Home every default account has superuser privileges and cannot belong to any domain) to enable it to achieve even a baseline level of security."

My question(s) are:

1) Am I as secure as the majority of average users can expect since I have installed

a) Comodo Firewall Pro(freeware) - (looking for in depth help manual; unsure if configured safely and unsure if configured optimally)
b) nod32 2.7(purchased) - (configured according to Blackspear's recommendations( http://www.wildersse...ead.php?t=37509 )
c) Comodo BOclean(freeware) - (configured according to http://www.comodo.co...tml#bocinstall; followed boclean advice to enable shares for boc424 folder via safe mode)
d) SnoopFree Privacy Shield 1.0.7(freeware)
e) Cyberhawk Pro(5 days into 15 day trial)
f) Spybot Search and Destroy(freeware)
g) Spywareblaster(freeware) - (Do I need to open and close this per computing session to be protected or do I run it once after each update of it?)
h) Put mvps.org( http://www.mvps.org/...p2002/hosts.htm ) hosts file in place.
i) KeyScambler 1.2.3(freeware)
J) McAfee SiteAdvisor 26.3(freeware)
k) NoScript
l) I followed instructions on microsoft.com to clear pagefile.sys at shutdown by changing a registry value.

2) Do any of the aforementioned applications conflict with each other?

3) Will I, as an average computer user, benefit from the "extra security" that Berkely Labs says Windows Professional can give me or should I just save the $200 that the Windows Pro upgrade will cost?

4) Is ccleaner safe to use on my xp sp2 in terms of manipulating registry, etc? I ask because I trialed the full version of what, in my opinion, is a similar product by Ashampoo on a windows 2000 professional sp4 installation on another machine. After that use it appears that my recycle bin will no longer function properly. There are times when recycle bin icon shows that it has contents, but when I open recycle bin I can not see any. When I delete files on that machine they go straight to permanent delete and, I can not get it to use recycle bin any longer. I exhausted a tremendous amount of time searching online for fixes. I have, in the past, had good results with resolving computer issues by searching online, but this is one that I have had no success with. Needless to say I have no plans to use the Ashampoo product again, but I am considering ccleaner.

I tried Online Armor w/ Firewall, but I seemed to be getting conflicts with the other security applications.

System Safety Monitor is, I am convinced, an excellent program, but it is "over my average user head" and I can not find a good help or configuration manual. Again, I believe it is among the best IF you know how to use it.

CyberHawk really seems to be "on the job"(got a number of alerts), but I am still unsure if I need to spend $24.95 to buy it.

SnoopFree seems to be "on the job" as well. I believe a couple of the security applications I am running might be "fighting with each other", but I don't know which ones.

Maybe I did not investigate enough but I installed Dynamic Security Agent and found that it would not start in the "limited user" account that I prefer to go online with so I unistalled it rather quickly. What did do wrong?

I downloaded Prevx, but I have not installed it yet. I like the trial offer of no cost until it stops a malaware, but I am uncomfortable with the way I understand it to work(constantly analyzing what files I am using through the "prevx servers"). To me I am not sure if my privacy is being violated or not and, even if not, it just seems really easy for someone, or something, to do so using the "prevx" running on my machine. I just feel like I would be giving "prevx" my permission to spy on me. Seems like software Privacy Statements and EULAs are "rigged" and difficult to understand enough without me going and allowing such a "setup" to run on my machine. I also did a lot of searching(problems with prevx), etc, especially at wilders, for prevx problems. It seems to me like I found too many serious issues like "blue screens", "crashes", etc.

I know that I need a firewall and av, but I really feel that I need a good HIPS or HIPS type security application running on my xp sp2 machine as well. But which HIPS do i choose?
  • 0




    Member 2k

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,383 posts
not safe, the history of malware on windows makes an interesting read but nothing is 100% for long or else this forum malware section would not be here and we would all be using the same protection. Personally, I like the idea of a linux live cd to do the internet where the IP address changes with each session and where the harddrive is both unused and bypassed, where the emails are done on the server and where linux being only 2% of the computer market the malware makers are not going to bother going out of their way to hack us, and joy or joys this does not cost me any money beyond the price of the cd I burn linux to.

OK, it sounds odd to be doing the internet without the harddrive but often enough it is quite easy to store things on the server
  • 0




  • Topic Starter
  • Member
  • PipPip
  • 36 posts
Thanks for responding fleamailman. I am not disagreeing with you. I like the idea of Linux, or even maybe an Apple, as well, but all that is "over my head" and wallet for the moment. I am just an "average joe". I am looking for advice on how to secure this XP sp2 machine that I am using well enough that it is highly unlikely that the majority of malware, viruses, hackers, spyware, whoever, are going to breach my defenses.

I know there must be plenty of XP sp2 home user "geeks" who run a similar setup to mine and can easily advise me as to how to secure the machine with applications that are easily accessible to the "average joe".
  • 0



    Trusted Tech

  • Retired Staff
  • 909 posts
Entire books could be (and have been) written about your subject.

In short, yes. You are doing very well, and there are those who would cry overkill.

BUT. Security is really only as good as the user. All the protection in the world won't help me if I bring the baddies home myself by visiting a "wrong" site or opening a "wrong" file.

Use 1:
active anti-spyware client
HIPS client

More than one of each may cause system problems, and may even result in decreased protection. So, either BOClean or Spybot Teatimer, but not both.
Just update Spywareblaster and "enable protection." That's it till next update.
Not familiar with SnoopFree Privacy Shield or KeyScambler so cannot comment.

I use several anti-spyware utilities as scanners, and also use an on-line anti-virus scanner, but have only one of each active on my system.

CCleaner seems to be reported by many as "safe" in regards to "issues," but even if uncleaned, the "issues" in the Registry will not noticiably impact performance.

I used "Home" for a long time with no problems. Just keep it updated.

For extra secuity, investigate "Sandbox" applications for your browser.
Sandboxie is free: http://www.sandboxie...wnloadSandboxie

Even if you have but one computer, a router provides a strong measure of extra protection.

For how I have layered my defenses, see my Vox: http://doc1101.vox.com/
Scroll down the page to "Security."

PS: You have already demonstrated that you are not an ordinary user!
  • 0

Similar Topics

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

As Featured On:

Microsoft Yahoo BBC MSN PC Magazine Washington Post HP