I picked EVGA due to their Step-Up Program. It's your decision on whether you want that or Company of Heroes. They both have limited lifetime warranties, so I'm not sure what James was referring to by saying XFX had a better warranty.
It's a better warranty because of the following.
-Warranty is transferable to the new owner of the card, should you resale it. Therefor it's resale value is greater then other cards.
-Warranty will not be voided with a few mods. This doesn't include hard mods such as volt mods.
-Overclocking is covered.
I'm pretty sure I'm missing something, but XFX's warranty is better. As for the step-up program, while it's a good idea, you're left without a card for 2-3 weeks.
Also if you live outside of the USA, shipping charges become pretty brutal.
Edited by james_8970, 11 February 2008 - 10:31 AM.