I think the problem might be that I have a very new graphics card (8800GTS 512mb). I have tried the 169.25 beta, 169.25 WHQL, and 169.28 beta drivers, which are the only 3 with support for my card. I get the same results with all of them.
Will a driver update or crysis patch hopefully solve this problem? It's kind of ironic that I got Crysis with my 8800gts 512mb and it doesn't work with it.